Connect with us

Middle East

ArcelorMittal Loses Court Case Against Reporter in Kazakhstan



A court city of central Kazakhstan has ruled in favour of a journalist in a libel suit filed by ArcelorMittal –  a major international metals and mining company.  The Temirtau court on January 29 determined that online postings by Oleg Gusev about ArcelorMittal Temirtau general director Paramjit Kahlon were intended only as irreverent irony and could not, therefore, be deemed actionable. 

At first blush, the case appears to represent a rare victory for Kazakhstan’s independent media, which is routinely cowed into submission through costly lawsuits filed by officials and rich businessmen.

Gusev has long been a thorn in the side of ArcelorMittal Temirtau, but the trigger for this particular case could not have been more childish and petty.

On May 9, a date that marks the anniversary of the Soviet Union’s victory over Nazi Germany, company press secretary Alexei Agureyev posted a photo on his Facebook page showing Kahlon shaking hands with a war veteran. In comments under the image, Gusev, who has written elsewhere and more seriously about what he deems to be ArcelorMittal Temirtau’s harmful practices, mocked Kahlon, describing him as a sympathizer of Nazi-allied Ukrainian nationalist militants during World War II. He used the disparaging term Banderovets — a Russian neologism derived from the name of wartime Ukrainian nationalist leader Stepan Bandera — to refer to the Indian-born executive.

A few days later, Gusev went further, posting images of Kahlon alongside one of Conchita Wurst, the drag persona of Austrian singer Thomas Neuwirth, who won the Eurovision Song Contest in 2014. Gusev had fed the two pictures into an online application called Twins or Not and came up with a similarity ranking of 66 percent.

After these two online stunts, patience snapped at ArcelorMittal Temirtau. The company argued that by likening Kahlon to Conchita Wurst, Gusev was making improper suggestions about the mining executive’s sexual orientation and had thereby “discredited the business reputation of the plaintiff.” Suggesting that Kahlon, who formerly headed an ArcelorMittal subsidiary in Ukraine, was a supporter of Bandera was also an insult, the company said.

A psychological and philological expert gave testimony in the Temirtau court to argue that there was no evidence to support the miner’s claims, however. Gusev has said that he believes the libel case was a reprisal for the reporting he has done about ArcelorMittal Temirtau’s damaging impact on the environment.

The antagonists may be set for another round in the courts.

In October, police revealed that they had opened a criminal case against Galymzhan Kunakbayev, a senior executive at ArcelorMittal Temirtau, on suspicion of unlawfully obstructing Gusev’s professional activities. Gusev claims that Kunakbayev threatened to cancel a deal with an ArcelorMittal Temirtau contractor that employs his son-in-law as a form of intimidation. The investigation is still ongoing.

People in the independent media scene have said that Gusev’s case could serve as a valuable precedent by upholding the position of a journalist against that of major industrial concern.

The optimism may be overstated, however. It is suggested in some quarters that the ArcelorMittal Temirtau libel case may actually really be part of a larger and unseen squabble among business and political elites. That would make the significance of the case less to do with media rights than politics.

The real breakthrough would, for those concerned with the viability of a free press, be to see a change in libel laws and the creation of a more level playing field for non-state-funded outlets.

More News at EurAsian Times




US-Drone-Strike US-Drone-Strike
Americas4 hours ago

US Looks To Replace Its Deadly MQ-9 Reaper Drones & Northrop Unveils A New ‘Breakthrough’ Concept

As the U.S. Air Force seeks a replacement for the MQ-9 Reaper drone, US defense giants Lockheed Martin, Northrop Grumman...

People's Liberation Army People's Liberation Army
Asia Pacific5 hours ago

Why China Again Wants To Seize ‘Despang Plains’ Just Like The 1962 India-China War?

The Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) may be actually eyeing the Depsang plains while creating a diversion in Pangong Tso...

Moon-Space-Station Moon-Space-Station
Americas6 hours ago

WATCH: US Secretive Spaceplane That Was Dubbed To ‘Spy On China’s 1st Space Station’

A video of the US’ veiled spaceplane X-37B was posted by a twitter user showing the plane’s cargo bay doors...

Indian-Air-Force Indian-Air-Force
Asia Pacific6 hours ago

China Prepares For A Possible Invasion By Indian Air Force Jets Led By Su-30 MKIs & Rafales

Bracing itself for an aerial attack by the Indian Air Force (IAF) on its airbases, China has reportedly begun planning...

Asia Pacific18 hours ago

China Says PLA Drills Not Warning, But Rehearsal For Taiwan Takeover

Tensions between China and Taiwan have dangerously deteriorated as Beijing has vowed to merge the 'renegade province' at any cost....

Maldives Maldives
Asia Pacific22 hours ago

Maldives Could Relinquish Control Of An Island As Chinese Loan & Pressure Mounts?

The Maldives government is now alarmed at the amount of debt it owes to China. With the coronavirus pandemic, the...

j20-vs-tejas j20-vs-tejas
Expert Reviews22 hours ago

Chinese J-20s Outgun Rafale Jets In Simulation Drills But What Will Happen In A Real-Life Air Battle?

China has been trying to intimidate India with its fifth-generation, stealth, J-20 fighter jets with the indigenously produced warplanes shooting...

World-Economic-Forum World-Economic-Forum
Featured23 hours ago

India-China Cyber War: China Second Most Powerful Cyber-Power & India Could Face The Chinese Brunt

As India and China are engaged in prolonged border tensions, India is boosting its capability to deal with cyber-attacks given...

china-detention-camps china-detention-camps
Asia Pacific23 hours ago

China Releases White Paper To Explain Its Commitment Towards Xinjiang & Uighur Muslims

Many Uighurs – around 1 million to 1.6 million, according to the World Uyghur Congress – have left China to...

Asia Pacific1 day ago

China Confirms PLA Soldiers Were Killed In Galwan Valley Clash; Claims India Suffered More

China has finally admitted that its soldiers indeed suffered casualties in the barbaric India-China border clash in Galwan Valley. The...