Connect with us

Expert Reviews

India, Pakistan, Autonomy or Freedom: What is the Permanent Solution to the Kashmir Dispute?



Is granting autonomy the best solution to the Kashmir Dispute? Is freedom or merging with either India or Pakistan really an option? Former Jammu and Kashmir CM Omar Abdullah recently asserted that granting autonomy is the most pragmatic solution the Kashmir crisis, while people in the Kashmir region have been raising slogans like “Azadi” or Freedom. 

Former J&K CM Abdullah said: “It is high time for the Government of India to implement the resolution of autonomy. “It is the only pragmatic solution to the age-old problem. J&K is a unique state and needs a special dispensation in terms of regional autonomy to satisfy the needs of the state,” said Omar, addressing a provincial meet of party functionaries.

Can Autonomy be Granted to Jammu and Kashmir

Kashmir dispute cannot be unfortunately resolved until and unless Pakistan is also included. But Pakistan, due to its terror policies, has been sponsoring terrorism in India and Indian Home Minister Rajnath Sigh has stated clearly: “Terrorism and Talks Cannot Go Hand-in-Hand”. India and Pakistan may engage in serious peace process and negotiations by end of 2019 when the Indian general elections are over.

Secondly, when we compare India with Pakistan, both nations are strikingly different. One one hand, Islamabad is in deep financial debt and facing a massive economic crisis, while India continues to be the world’s fastest growing economy. India has gradually emerged as the world’s economic powerhouse, while a small nation like Bangladesh has surpassed Pakistan in economic growth rate and human development index.

Pakistan is not in a position to negotiate with India on an equal footing and does not really expect India to make concessions on any matter, including Kashmir. Pakistan has been vehemently advocating for talks with India and if the Indus water treaty and Siachen matter can be amicably resolved, Islamabad may be forced to re-look at its Kashmir Policy.

Thirdly, granting autonomy might sound an interesting option to Omar Abdullah, but he is not in the power at present. Abdullah knows and understands that an independent Kashmir may become a breeding ground for radicals which will eventually result in a massive civil war in Kashmir just like Syria or Iraq.

Kashmir may be troubled, no doubt, but the majority of people who get injured or killed are either militants, paid recruits or violent stone pelters. However, innocent people are still living safely in the valley and once the Indian Army leaves, there is a strong possibility that violent mobs will create havoc in the valley and do irreversible damage to the situation. New Delhi will never let that happen.

Lastly, what people do not understand that both India and Pakistan have somewhat agreed to the fact that there will be no redrawing of the boundaries and independence is not an option on the table for Kashmir.

Regions like Jammu and Ladakh will never want to unlink themselves with India and have supported the trifurcation of the state. The minority community in Kashmir will also not support Kashmiri Sunni Muslims for their quest (including Kashmiri Pandits, Sikhs and Shia Muslims – who vehemently oppose Pakistan). There is a limited influence of “Azadi” in Northern Kashmir and Gujjar-Bakarwal community who live very close to the border areas with Pakistan.

Also, don’t forget, if India has to grant autonomy or freedom to Kashmir, then Pakistan will also have to reciprocate by granting autonomy/freedom to Gilgit-Baltistan (GB) and other occupied regions where Chinese CPEC project is passing through (worth a whopping $60 Billion USD).

What will Islamabad do in case the new Kashmir / GB Government decides to block the Chinese CPEC project? Clearly, Pakistan will not put their country at stake for the Kashmir cause and will prefer to stick to the status quo just like India.

More News at EurAsian Times




US-China-Trade-War US-China-Trade-War
Asia Pacific1 hour ago

Chinese Navigation System Beidou Has Surpassed US’ GPS In Over 165 Countries : Reports

The vanguard of navigation systems, the US’ Global Positioning System (GPS), is losing its dominance to China’s Beidou satellite navigation...

putin-russia putin-russia
EurAsian Region2 hours ago

Russia Ready For Doomsday, Its ‘Deeply Buried’, Underground Nuclear Command Bunker Is Almost Complete

In a high-profile meeting held at the Kremlin on 11 November, Russian President Vladimir Putin discussed the completion of a...

Americas2 hours ago

TANK FOR SALE: A Grizzly Variant of Sherman Tank Goes Under The Hammer, Fetching Up To $500,000

Yes, a 1943 M4A1 Grizzly, an adaptation of the Sherman medium tank that was built in Canada in late 1943,...

jet jet
Featured3 hours ago

Why AMRAAM-ER, The World’s Most Powerful Beyond Visual Range (BVR) Missile Can Be A Game Changer In The Middle-East?

 The Middle East is clearly witnessing an arms race. The United Arab Emirates (UAE) will soon become the first country...

Featured5 hours ago

China Adopting US’ “Disruptive Strategy” Against India As Ladakh Border Tensions Remain Unresolved

India is one of the worst-hit countries by the Covid-19 pandemic, with its economy entering a ‘technical recession’ phase. The...

Asia Pacific5 hours ago

Taiwan Counters Chinese Threats By Inaugurating Indigenous Submarines That Will Be Equipped With Deadly Harpoon Missiles

In a bid to safeguard the island territory from mainland China, Taiwan’s President Tsai Ing-wen vowed to protect the sovereignty...

Featured6 hours ago

Israel Wants Pakistan’s Nuclear Teeth Broken & Saudi Arabia Could Land The First Punch

OPED By Haider Abbas

nato nato
Americas15 hours ago

The Wrong Move: NATO Chief Warns Of ‘Imminent Threats’ Of Pulling-Out From Afghanistan

Speaking at the virtually held 2020 Afghanistan Donors’ Conference, NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said the mission had already significantly ‘adjusted’...

f-35-f-22-usa f-35-f-22-usa
Expert Reviews15 hours ago

Battle Of Stealth Brothers: Why US’ F-22 Raptors Can Decimate F-35 Jets In One-On-One Encounter?

Amid the race to built sixth-generation fighter jets by a host of countries including the United States, the United Kingdom,...

f35 f35
Americas18 hours ago

Lockheed Martin Awarded Contract To Integrate AARGM-ER Missiles With USAF’ F-35A Jets

The US Air Force is moving closer to the integration of an advanced air-defense busting missile to its newest F-35A...