Saturday, April 10, 2021

Despite ‘Bitter Rivalry’, India, China Unlikely To Nuke Each Other — SIPRI

India and China may have engaged in multiple border skirmishes since the 1962 war, but a nuclear war between the two neighbors is not only unlikely but also unthinkable, according to a report by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI).   

Indian and Chinese troops had disengaged in February after a 10-month-long border standoff in eastern Ladakh. The episode also included the deadly Galwan Valley clash between their soldiers in June last year. India had lost 20 of its soldiers while China officially admitted four casualties, that too six months after the incident.  

Despite such volatility in their relations, the two countries are unlikely to press the nuclear buttons, the SIPRI report titled ‘South Asia’s Nuclear Challenges’ says.

“Among Chinese and Indian experts, there was a prevailing view that they shared the same stance on no first use, and that nuclear escalation between the two countries was not only unlikely but also unthinkable,” the Swedish think tank’s report claims. 

“In most cases, there was a steadfast view that both countries were on the same page when it came to nuclear posture, with NFU (no-first-use) as just one example.”

The India-China disengagement in eastern Ladakh.

The SIPRI report was based on interviews with 119 experts from India, China, the US, Russia, and Pakistan.

The experts also argue that India only “superficially” understands its opponent, and stressed the need for more bilateral dialogues between New Delhi and Beijing. They drew attention to China’s unwillingness to engage India, citing the latter’s non-accession to the NPT (Non-Proliferation Treaty) as an excuse. Yet these same experts also stressed the stabilizing properties of the two countries’ similar nuclear postures.

Currently, China and India are the only two nuclear-armed nations in the world to adopt an NFU policy. It refers to a pledge or a policy by a nuclear power not to use these weapons as a means of warfare unless first attacked by an adversary using nuclear munitions. India’s NFU policy is also applicable to chemical and biological warfare.

China’s aggressive postures in the region have always been questioned by experts, and its strong relations with Pakistan have already put India into a two-front war preparedness and maintain relations with the United States.

On China and the USA, experts from each county tended to see the other as playing a larger and more destabilizing role in South Asia. Chinese experts focused on past US weapon sales to the region, the Indian–US nuclear deal, the US Indo-Pacific Strategy, and the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, which have had a strong focus on China as well as India.

US experts cited China’s conventional and nuclear weapons outreach to Pakistan, military training, and the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor under the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). This different focus and pattern of engagement led some US experts to express concern that the region could break into two camps, with the USA and India on one side and China and Pakistan on the other.

Follow EurAsian Times on Google News

Featured News

Watch The Russian ‘Super-Weapon’ That Reportedly Poses The Biggest Threat To The US Military

The US seems deeply concerned about what experts call the Russian "super-weapon" Poseidon 2M39 torpedo, according to reports. This comes amid the huge Russian...

Strategic Allies India & Vietnam Likely To Frame ‘Common Security Strategy’ To Counter China

India and Vietnam discussed their plans to increase military cooperation and joint strategies for regional development, amid Beijing's aggressive posture in the South China...

How Is India Countering The Growing Fleet Of French & Chinese Origin Submarines With The Pakistan Navy?

India is set to approve the indigenous construction of three nuclear-powered attack submarines to counter the Chinese PLA’s rapid expansion in the Indian Ocean. This...

New F4 Rafale Fighter Jets To Have Advanced Stealth & EWS; Is India A Potential Customer?

France is developing an advanced version of its Rafale fighter aircraft that would come with enhanced stealth, powerful electronic warfare systems, and new weapons. The...

Did IAF Chief Fly SU-30MKI Fighter Jet To Check On Latest Upgrades Including BrahMos & MICA Missiles?

Indian Air Force (IAF) chief RKS Bhadauria flew a Sukhoi SU-30MKI in Bengaluru on Thursday to witness the fighter jet’s "capability enhancement", IAF said...