On December 31, 2024, Ukrainian forces successfully shot down a Russian Mi-8 helicopter using a Magura V5 naval drone equipped with R-73 “SeeDragon” missiles.
This operation, executed by Ukraine’s elite “Group 13” of the Main Directorate of Intelligence near Cape Tarkhankut in Russian-occupied Crimea, marks the first recorded instance of an unmanned surface vessel (USV) engaging and destroying an aerial target.
The drone launched the missile, reportedly hitting the helicopter mid-flight, while another helicopter sustained damage but managed to return to base. This innovative use of naval drones capable of launching air-to-air missiles highlights Ukraine’s adaptability in modern warfare, effectively countering Russian aerial threats in the Black Sea region.
Magura V5 USV
The Magura V5 is a Ukrainian multi-purpose unmanned surface vehicle (USV) designed for a variety of naval operations, including surveillance, reconnaissance, mine countermeasures, maritime security, and combat missions.
The drone measures 5.5 meters in length and 1.5 meters in width and sits 500 mm above the waterline, providing a compact yet effective platform for naval operations. It boasts an impressive range of up to 800 kilometers, allowing it to cover vast areas of the Black Sea. Its approximately 75-80 km/h speed facilitates rapid deployment and tactical maneuvering.
The Magura V5 can carry a payload of up to 320 kg, including explosives for kamikaze missions or specialized equipment for different operational needs.
It features an autopilot system, video subsystems with night vision capabilities, and redundant communication modules, ensuring reliable operation and control from a ground-based autonomous station. This setup supports both remote piloting and pre-programmed autonomous missions.
Equipped with advanced GPS and cameras, the Magura V5 transmits live video back to operators, providing real-time intelligence and situational awareness. It also boasts up to 60 hours of battery life, enabling extended missions without frequent recharging or refueling.
Russian Countermeasures
Due to its speed and maneuverability, the Magura V5 is difficult to target using aerial platforms equipped with guns or rockets.
While guided weapons are more effective, their use poses challenges as well. These USVs present low thermal contrast targets, reducing the effectiveness of infrared (IR) homing systems. Additionally, sea wave clutter degrades radar homing efficiency.
Russia has deployed attack helicopters like the Ka-27/29 and Mi-8, along with combat aircraft such as Su-27/30/35 and MiG-29, to counter the Magura V5. However, fighter aircraft must fly low and slow to engage the USVs, increasing their exposure to air defense (AD) weapons. Since their weapon systems are optimized for long-range attacks against static targets, they often resort to gunfire to engage USVs.
Air-to-surface missiles launched from helicopters and manually guided through optical seekers have proven most effective in countering USVs.
Ukrainian Riposte
Ukraine has progressively upgraded the Magura V5 to thwart Russian countermeasures. By equipping the drone with R-73 air-to-air missiles, Ukraine has enabled it to engage aerial threats, as demonstrated in the recent incident.
Efforts are underway to reduce the drone’s radar and electromagnetic signatures, possibly incorporating brief diving or submersion capabilities to enhance stealth against Russian detection systems.
Starlink Networking
The Magura V5 is remotely operated using the Starlink satellite network. While Russian forces employ sophisticated electronic warfare (EW) systems to disrupt drone communications, navigation, and targeting, they have struggled to jam Starlink effectively.
Advantage Ukraine
The success of Ukrainian forces in downing Russian helicopters attacking USVs has significantly altered the balance of naval power in the Black Sea in Ukraine’s favor.
Russian forces are now compelled to deploy expensive fighter aircraft assets to counter Ukrainian USV operations. This reduces the number of Russian fighters available for air superiority missions. Fighter operations also face limitations in bad weather and nighttime conditions, making them less effective.
The Russian Navy’s surface fleet remains vulnerable to USV attacks, capable of protecting itself only within bays and bases. Consequently, the Russian fleet cannot ensure the safe passage of its commercial shipping in the Black Sea.
Russian Options
Long-range kamikaze drones, such as the Geran-2, which use AI for autonomous target recognition, are ineffective against USVs due to their high speed and maneuverability.
One potential option for Russian forces is to intensify attacks on Ukrainian coastal bases used to launch USVs. However, this approach has limited payoff because identifying all launch points is challenging. Furthermore, USVs can be launched from ships, including merchant vessels.
While Russia could theoretically target these ships with submarines or long-range anti-shipping missiles, identifying them would require advanced human intelligence (HUMINT) and intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) capabilities—areas where Russia appears to be lacking.
Innovative technical solutions include developing and deploying mines triggered by vessels exceeding certain speed thresholds. However, such mines would require significant time and resources to develop and deploy.
Ukrainian USVs likely use makeshift optical sensors to acquire aerial targets such as helicopters and launch short-range missiles that home in using IR/optical seekers. These drones are too small to deploy radar systems. Russian forces could exploit this weakness by using armed drones to strike USVs from a safe distance.
Russian Orion MALE drones possess the sensors and guided weapons theoretically capable of engaging Ukrainian USVs. However, their absence in significant numbers suggests that either their weapons systems are not optimized for maritime targets or Russia lacks sufficient numbers to patrol the Black Sea effectively.
Conclusion
Through the use of relatively low-cost USVs, Ukraine has made offense much cheaper than defense, gaining a strategic advantage over Russia.
To neutralize Ukrainian USVs, Russia would need to deploy large numbers of drones, mines, or surface vessels—a resource-intensive strategy. Moreover, Ukrainian USVs are likely to evolve further, potentially incorporating MLRS and EW capabilities to tighten the noose around Russia’s Black Sea Fleet.
- Vijainder K Thakur is a retired IAF Jaguar pilot, author, software architect, entrepreneur, and military analyst.
- VIEWS PERSONAL OF THE AUTHOR
- Follow the author @vkthakur
