Connect with us

Featured

India and Pakistan Celebrating – But Who Emerged Victorious in Kulbhushan Jadhav Case?

Published

on

With the International Court of Justice (ICJ) finally giving verdict on much-awaited Kulbhushan Jadhav case, both Pakistan and India claimed victory. The narrative in Indian media paints a different picture of the judgment while Pakistan is displaying a totally different side of the story. So who won, India or Pakistan?

After ICJ Ruling, Pakistan ‘Officially’ Grants Consular Access to Kulbhushan Jadhav

PAKISTAN’S WIN:

According to the International Court of Justice, Jadhav’s conviction and sentence by a military court were not to be regarded as a violation of Article 36 of the Vienna Convention, which India had claimed.

“As regards India’s claim based on the Vienna Convention, the court considers that it is not the conviction and sentence of Jadhav which are to be regarded as a violation of the provisions of the Vienna Convention,” read the verdict.

Article 36 states that foreign nationals who are arrested or detained be given notice without delay of their right to have their embassy and consulate be notified of the arrest and have consular officers visit them.

Among other Indian demands were the annulment of the military court’s decision and permitting Jadhav a safe passage to India. However, the same was denied.

Govt of Pakistan Tweet

Big win for Pakistan. India’s demand of release and repatriation of rejected by ICJ.

INDIA’S WIN:

India had also demanded that Jadhav be tried once again by a civilian court after giving him consular access. No retrial was granted, however, Pakistan was ordered to grant the convicted spy consular access.

India also demanded the relief of “review and reconsideration” for Jadhav, which ICJ granted, but by means of Pakistan’s own choice.

It simply means that Islamabad will have to give consular access to Jadhav which India has been demanding for a long time. A day after the ruling of International Court of Justice (ICJ), Pakistan on has officially declared to grant consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav.

The announcement was made by Pakistan Foreign Office in a statement in which it said the decision to grant consular access to Indian Naval officer was taken in line with the ICJ decision.

“Pursuant to the decision of the ICJ, Commander Kulbhushan Jadhav has been informed of his rights under Article 36, Paragraph 1(b) of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. As a responsible state, Pakistan will grant consular access to Commander Kulbushan Jadhav according to Pakistani laws, for which modalities are being worked out,” said the brief statement

FOREIGN MEDIA:

Meanwhile, international media reports focused on the ICJ’s directive to Pakistan to review its death sentence to Kulbhushan Jadhav.

“World Court Orders Review of Pakistan Death Sentence for Indian Convicted of Spying”, The New York Times‘ headline said. The Washington Post story on the judgment said: “Alleged Indian spy on death row in Pakistan wins a reprieve from execution”.

British media also focussed on the part of the ICJ judgment which went in India’s favour. “UN court orders Pakistan not to execute Indian man accused of spying,” The Guardian said in its report.

KULBHUSHAN JADHAV

As per the allegations of Pakistan, Kulbhushan Jadhav was arrested in an intelligence-based operation in March 2016 from Balochistan after he crossed the border from Iran. He was travelling on a fake name but original Indian passport.

In a recorded video statement, he later confessed of working for RAW and involved in subversive activities both in Balochistan and Karachi, a claim rejected by India. New Delhi said Jadhav was pressurized to give these statement and requested Islamabad for consular access which was rejected that time.

In April 2017, the military court had sentenced Jadhav to death for his involvement in espionage and subversive activities. He later filed a clemency petition before army chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa. His mercy plea was still pending before him.

Meanwhile, India approached the ICJ against Pakistan for not granting consular access to Jadhav. Pakistan repeatedly denied consular access requests based on its interpretation of the bilateral agreement that did not extend the consular facility to spies.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Facebook

FEATURED

ashar-ghani ashar-ghani
Featured4 hours ago

Afghanistan, Turkmenistan Sign Deal On TAPI Pipeline Which Includes India & Pakistan

Turkmenistan and Afghanistan on Wednesday signed documents to promote the implementation of joint infrastructure projects, according to Turkmenistan’s Foreign Ministry...

INDIA-PAKISTAN-CHINA INDIA-PAKISTAN-CHINA
Americas6 hours ago

India-Pakistan War Much More ‘Imminent & Beneficial’ For Delhi Than A Conflict With China – Top US Analyst

India has been on the edge of a potential war with two of its neighbours – China and Pakistan. While...

Modi-Government Modi-Government
Featured6 hours ago

Is India Under PM Modi Drifting Away From Gandhi’s Non-Violent Doctrine?

Coinciding the birth anniversary of India’s freedom icon, Mahatma Gandhi on Friday, experts say his values of non-violent resistance have...

INDIA-CHINA INDIA-CHINA
Europe12 hours ago

Like India, Greece To Equip Its Rafale Fighter Jets With HAMMER Missiles?

HAMMER (Highly Agile and Manoeuvrable Munition Extended Range) missiles are air to ground precision-guided missiles developed by Safran Electronics &...

F-15EX-india F-15EX-india
Americas21 hours ago

Forget F-16s & F-35s, This Is The World’s Deadliest Fighter Jet With 100 Kills, Without A Single Loss

Over the years, the United States has developed a strategic military partnership with Israel by equipping them with the world’s...

putin-russia putin-russia
EurAsian Region23 hours ago

Russian Sukhoi Su-34 Jet Displays ‘Path-Breaking’ Capabilities; Makes Its First Flight Into The Stratosphere

Russian fighter-bomber aircraft Su-34 carried out a night-time combat exercise reaching to the heights of 15 kilometers at lower stratospheric...

Putin-Macron Putin-Macron
Europe1 day ago

French President Emmanuel Macron Blames Azerbaijan For Starting Conflict With Armenia

French President Emmanuel Macron on Wednesday voiced solidarity with Armenia amid its conflict with Azerbaijan over disputed Upper Karabakh region....

Israel-Turkey Israel-Turkey
Europe1 day ago

Greece Turning Into Another Israel: The Way US Backed Israel, EU Is Supporting Greece – Turkish Experts

With growing military confrontations in the Eastern Mediterranean between Greece and Turkey, several European Union (EU) nations have got itself...

Indian-Flag Indian-Flag
Featured1 day ago

200,000 Muslim Children Disappeared From Uttarakhand Overnight: Another Smear Campaign Or Truth?

A news is getting viral on WhatsApp and Social media in India which EurAsian Times has access to. The news...

INDIA-CHINA-WAR INDIA-CHINA-WAR
Asia Pacific1 day ago

How India, China Conflict In Ladakh Is Becoming A ‘Test Platform’ For Drone Technology?

In a bid to compete with one another, India and China have been deploying their heavy weaponry and latest armaments...

Advertisement