Connect with us

Asia Pacific

Why Are India, China Issuing ‘Contradicting Statements’ Over Border Disengagement Process?



India and China are actively involved in the disengagement process after the dangerous military standoff and clash that took place in Galwan Valley. Although the military commandments and diplomatic officials are still negotiating, there are contrasting statements about the withdrawal from Beijing and New Delhi.

When India-China Diplomatic Row ‘Almost Erupted’ Into A Full Scale War In 1967

As reported by Hindustan Times, both countries are now considering the option of putting patrolling protocols in place to avoid a repeat of the June 15 Galwan Valley flare-up.

“The first step is total disengagement, then de-escalation with minimum troops being kept by both sides as per 1993-1996 bilateral agreements and then some working mechanism where the patrolling parties of two sides do not clash,” said a senior official, requesting anonymity.

The fifth round of talks between 14 Corps commander Lt-General Harinder Singh and South Xinjiang Military District chief Major General Liu Lin concluded on Sunday. As per the report by Times of India, the Indian side discussed the disengagement process from Pangong Tso lake and Gogra area with the Chinese troops.

Indian Army Fears A Repeat Of Siachen Conflict But This Time With China

The negotiations were held amid the constant Chinese unwillingness to disengage fully on the north bank of Pangong Tso as well as Patrolling Point (PP)-17A at Gogra, let alone start de-escalation and eventual withdrawal of the over 30,000 soldiers each accumulated by both sides along the Line of Actual Control.

In contrast to this, Chinese ambassador, Sun Weidong said that on the northern bank of Pangong Lake, China’s traditional customary boundary line is in accordance with LAC. There is no such case that China has expanded its territorial claim.

China hopes that Indian troops will follow the agreements and protocols between the two countries and will not illegally cross the LAC. The common efforts of the two countries have led to the withdrawal of forces in most areas, and the tension at the ground level is reducing,” he added.

India Must Use Pakistan’s Military Doctrine To Challenge China’s Occupation Of Border Areas – Military Experts

Although India’s effort to restore the status quo is still nowhere on the horizon. “The military talks seem to be going nowhere, with the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) refusing to fully adhere to the disengagement process finalised during the fourth round of talks on July 14. Higher political-diplomatic intervention may be needed,” said an official.

According to Swaran Singh, professor and chair, Center for International Politics, Jawaharlal Nehru University, it isn’t surprising to see that India and China have different statements as both of them have a different understanding of the LAC.

“It is clear that China has not gone after what India considers LAC, but according to its interpretation of China, it is within its boundary.” Singh believes that it can also be a part of China’s ‘two steps forward and one step’ retreat strategy.

After Aksai Chin, China Dangerously Intruding Into Himachal Pradesh – India

Indian diplomat, P. Stobdan, said that de-escalation is a long process and the ground reality is better known to the government. “I’m sure that the government is conducting surveys to ascertain the regions where the army has retreated. We need to accept the information coming from them,” he added.

Singh believes that the statement of both countries that they want peace on the border along with the continuous dialogue and efforts at the military commandment level is a good sign.




Featured16 mins ago

After Ladakh, Why Another Part Of Jammu & Kashmir Could Be Engulfed In A Gruesome War?

In a bid to gain further control on the disputed Gilgit Baltistan region, Islamabad has decided to upgrade its status...

sharif-modi-meeting sharif-modi-meeting
Featured2 hours ago

Nawaz Sharif’s Speech Against Pakistan Army Widely Celebrated In India – Imran Khan

Pakistan PM Imran Khan denounced former PM Nawaz Sharif and stated that the opposition has only one agenda i.e. how...

Asia Pacific13 hours ago

Indian Army Has Deployed Additional 100,000 Troops Near The LAC – Top Chinese General

Despite the sixth round of Corps Commander level meeting between India and China which failed to provide any significant breakthrough,...

F18-India-Deal F18-India-Deal
Featured13 hours ago

NATO Commitment Forces Germany To Acquire F-18 Super Hornets & Reduce Number Of Typhoons

German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier is looking to procure the new Eurofighter Typhoons and F-18 Super Hornets to bridge the gap...

Expert Reviews15 hours ago

‘Hot Winters’ Ahead – China Says PLA Needs To Teach A Harsh Lesson To ‘Insincere’ India – OPED

The portents of war between China and India seem to be getting more and more darker by every passing day....

Featured21 hours ago

SAAB Delivers Gripen-E Jets To Brazil; Offers ‘Exceptional Deal’ To The Indian Air Force

With India’s new FDI model under the new indigenization drive, SAAB has seen it as a lucrative offer and is...

Europe22 hours ago

After Rafale Jets, This Air Force Wants Stealth F-35s That Was Once Meant For Turkey?

While some recent reports indicated that with the arrival of F-35s, UAE cold shed some of its F-16s and sell...

j20-vs-tejas j20-vs-tejas
Asia Pacific23 hours ago

Taiwanese Expert Says ‘Bathrooms Best Place To Hide’ During Chinese Air Raids, Missile Attack

As tensions between China and Taiwan are only increasing day by day, former Ministry of Defense advisor Sung Chao-wen on...

Featured1 day ago

Indian SU-30 MKI Jets Loaded With BrahMos Missiles Practice Hitting Chinese Assets Far Away From Ladakh

Soaring tensions between India and China in Ladakh has seen both the sides deploying thousands of troops, heavy artillery and...

China-and-India China-and-India
Asia Pacific1 day ago

India-China War Highly Unlikely; Beijing Only Testing Indian Resilience – Experts

India-China War: The joint statement following the meeting said that ministers had a “frank and constructive discussion on the developments...